A milkshake is ice cream and milk. A blender can make one. A drink mixer is what soda fountains used, and it still makes the thicker glass. These two cover both jobs.
As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. For a machine that also does daily smoothies, see the best blenders for smoothies and the best blenders roundup.
Which to buy
- Classic thick shake: Hamilton Beach DrinkMaster
- Family batch with ice cream and mix-ins: Ninja Professional Plus
How to mix it
Use two scoops of ice cream and about a half cup of milk per serving. Soften the ice cream for a minute so the blades or spindle catch it. Blend just until it is smooth. Extra time melts the ice cream and thins the shake. Add fruit or syrup after the base is moving, not before.
Hamilton Beach DrinkMaster
This is a spindle mixer, not a blade blender. Hamilton Beach lists the Chrome Classic (730N) with a 28 oz stainless cup, two speeds, and a tilt-back head. The cup rests on the body, so you are not holding a jar of ice cream. The spindle folds the shake instead of pulverizing it, which is why a fountain shake stays thick.
Buy it if the only job is malts, shakes, and iced coffee. Skip it for frozen fruit, kale, or a pitcher of smoothies. The cup is one or two servings, and the spindle has to be wiped after each use.
Check the Hamilton Beach DrinkMaster on Amazon
Ninja Professional Plus
The BN701 is the blender to use when the shake has cookies, frozen fruit, or a full pint of ice cream. Ninja lists a 1400-peak-watt base, a 72 oz pitcher with a 64 oz liquid line, stacked Total Crushing blades, and three Auto-iQ programs plus low, medium, high, and pulse. Use pulse, not a long high cycle. A long cycle melts the shake.
It is louder than the DrinkMaster, and the pitcher is plastic. It is the right pick if you also want smoothies from the same machine. It is the wrong pick if you want a spoon-thick fountain shake and nothing else.
Check the Ninja Professional Plus on Amazon
What to skip
A 250-watt personal blender will leave ice cream chunks and stall on a thick shake. A no-name 1800-watt countertop blender is not a better milkshake machine than these two. Do not fill a pitcher to the lid. Foam needs room, or the shake leaks out the pour spout.


